Menu Close

Creative destruction: The Covid-19 economic crisis is hastening the demise of fossil fuels

The fossil-fuel economy is obsolete
Peter Newman

“Bona Vista Oil Wells” by Tonyglen14 (licensed under CC BY 2.0)

Creative destruction “is the essential fact about capitalism”, wrote the great Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter in 1942. Newly developed technologies and processes continuously revolution- ise the economic structure from within, “incessantly destroying the old one, incessantly creating a new one”.

Change often happens more quickly and creatively during times of economic disruption. Innovations meeting material and cultural needs accelerate. Structures preventing the new, more efficient technologies weaken. As the old economy collapses, innovations “cluster” to become the core of the new economy.

Over the past three centuries there have been five great “waves” of economic disruption and clustering. The first was driven by harnessing water power, the second by steam power, the third by coal and electricity, the fourth by oil and gas, and the fifth by digital technology.

We are now at the start of the sixth great wave, driven by renewable energy combined with electromobility and smart-city technology.

Though 2020 will be a difficult year for the entire economy, these technology trends are faring much better than the old-energy sector. Over the longer run the COVID-19 economic disruption should accelerate the wave.

Renewable energy

In renewable energy, solar photovoltaics and onshore wind are now the most economic new form of electricity generation for at least two-thirds of the global population, according to energy research provider BloombergNEF.

The waves of innovation – waves and lifespans of technological change, 1785-2020, by Peter Newman (licensed under CC BY-ND)

In Australia, the latest analysis of electricity generation costs by the Australian Energy Market Operator and CSIRO shows solar photovoltaics and wind are already cheaper than coal and gas. Solar PV costs are also predicted to fall sharply over the next decade, reducing its generation costs from about A$50 a megawatt hour to A$30 by 2030.

The following graph for renewable energy and coal consumption in the United States shows the acceleration towards renewables is well underway.

Statistics published last week by the US Energy Information Administration show in 2019 coal production fell to its lowest level since 1978. In 2020 coal production is projected to fall to 1960s levels.

Across all of the member nations of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (including Australia),

the International Energy Agency’s latest monthly statistics show that coal production in April was down 32% on April 2019. Electricity generation from all non-renewables was down 12%. But electricity from renewables was up 3%.


Electromobility encompasses electric vehicles including cars, buses and trackless trams.

The energy research provider BloombergNEF projects that, globally, electric vehicles will comprise 3% of new passenger car sales in 2020, 10% in 2025, 28% in 2030 and 58% in 2040.

A sudden jump in renewable energy use – US coal and renewable energy consumption, quadrillion British thermal units, 1776-2019, by Peter Newman, redrawn from IEA (2020) (licensed under CC BY ND)

Leading the charge is Europe, where sales of electric vehicles actually increased 7.5% in the first quarter of 2020, bucking the global downturn for electric cars and the industry overall.

The only major car maker to increase sales was Tesla, selling 88,496 cars. Its second-quarter sales of 90,650 cars was just 5% down on a year ago, compared to falls of about 25% for other makers. Tesla’s booming share price saw it overtake Toyota in May to become the world’s most valuable car maker.

Smart-city technology

Smart-city technology involves using sensors, machine learning, artificial intelligence, block-chain and the “inter- net of things” to improve infrastructure efficiency. They have been growing in use for transport, energy and housing.

Road sensors can help traffic managers coordinate traffic signals to cut congestion or to guide fast electric buses and trackless trams through traffic. Apps help us navigate through cities, and to know precisely when buses or trains are due. In energy grids, smart technology can be used to balance electricity supply and demand, and to create low- cost and localised electricity markets.

In housing, smart systems can improve all aspects of a home’s energy and environmental performance. Curtin University has partnered with Western Australia’s land development agency to integrate these technologies into the East Village housing project located in Fremantle. It uses blockchain technology to leverage photovoltaics, batteries, electric vehicles and water heating in a micro-grid supplying 100% renewable power to 36 homes. This cluster of innovations are modular, so developers can experiment and then scale up.

Brake or accelerate

The economic and cultural benefits of renewable energy generation, electro-mobility and smart-city technologies are clear. They will led to a cleaner, greener economy with many more new jobs.

Together I estimate they have the potential to reduce the use of fossil fuel by 80% in a decade.

Eliminating the last 20% – gas and coal used in industrial processes such as steel production and mineral process- ing, and fossil fuels used for long-haul land, sea and air transport – will be harder.

But hydrogen made with renewable energy can potentially replace fossil fuels in all these applications, though developing and commercialising the technology and needed infrastructure will likely take a decade or more.

Australia is already a global leader in uptake of solar generation and battery storage. We are also doing well in smart city technologies. But we have been slow in electromobility, and will need further hydrogen research, development and deployment.

The only thing that will put the brake on these technologies becoming the core of the new economy sooner rather than later are backward-looking government policies that seek to prop up an obsol- ete fossil-fuel economy.

Source: The Conversation, 3 August 2020 destruction-the-covid-19-economic-crisis-is-accelerating-the-demise-of-fossil-fuels- 143739?

Dr Peter Newman is an environmental scientist author and educator, and is Professor of Sustain- ability at Curtin University In W.A.

Leave a Reply